12 Comments
User's avatar
Micah Durling's avatar

Just...lovely, Bethel. Truly. And, for what it's worth, no one truly understands the realitv that Jesus Paid it all. We'll have to wait for the beatific vision for that kind of understanding, and even then its just the beginning.

Expand full comment
Peter Mapes's avatar

Not being cheeky here, but consider what people like Scott Adams hear when we say Jesus paid it all, and if you don't trust the payment plan, He will torment you for all eternity... But maybe just maybe he really did pay it all - for - all...

Expand full comment
michael holt's avatar

Bethel, I agreed Scott wouldn't read this and I'm sure he won't, but I also doubted that you could make it a worthwhile read for me. I was right until the last two sentences.

Expand full comment
Christopher Check's avatar

This is a beautiful letter, Bethel.

Expand full comment
Tim Iversen's avatar

I have listened to Scott Adams for the better part of 4 years, every weekday on my walks. There is much to admire. I secretly wished he'd convert, and prayed for it as well. Your question to him:"Does truth make you happy?" I believe can be answered in the affirmative for Scott. He's always come across honest to me, but like all of us, fallen, flawed, and in need of a Savior. His daily grind for truth I hope will overcome the narcissistic wounds, whose effect he recognizes, and bring him to his knees.

My subscription to you lapsed, and honestly, I've been pondering if I could live without your paid content. I can't. This "open letter" made an old man cry. Thank you, Bethel.

Expand full comment
Bethel McGrew's avatar

That is so kind of you, thanks for resubscribing and commenting! This particular post is free but there's exclusive content coming. I appreciate your patience and your support. :)

Expand full comment
John Bauman's avatar

When I read that Adams said "he (might?) will convert to Christianity" to my ears it sounded like a foreign language. I think it was Jonah Goldberg who hilariously described Mitt Romney as "speaking 'conservative' like a second language". If you knew, you knew. It was funny. Romney wasn't a conservative, but trying to win over a significant enough part of the Republican Party to win an election, he had to try to sound like one. He didn't (sound like one). And if you knew, you knew.

Saying that I will (at some point -- even immanently) convert to Christianity sounds like a foreign understanding of Christianity and how I might identify with/as it.

And though it's yet another political reference I'm using to make a non-political point, it misses the point that George Will always made trying to explain to people that he wasn't a Republican. He just voted Republican because, of the choices available to him, that party better defined principles he did believe in.

If you are going to convert to Christianity, you have.

Except for the fact that if you describe it as "I will be converting to Christianity", you haven't.

Expand full comment
Paul's avatar

Bethel, it would be interesting to read you unpack Jesus’ ransom as best you can. Why did Jesus have to die? It makes sense for me as a Christian, but I still struggle on if I can articulate it well enough to someone who wonders why He had to die. Not looking for a polished dissertation, just some halfway coherent musings would be enlightening!

Expand full comment
Allen Baldwin's avatar

Jesus paid it all! Amen!

It still seems you stopped mid sentence.

Expand full comment
James A. Weaks's avatar

Okay, I'm confused. You told him, correctly, that "...it’s not Christianity." This was great, then you stopped. Why didn't you tell him what it is? I've seen the replies online. There is no shortage of awful people saying awful things, and also good, well-intentioned people telling him plenty of things Christianity is not. Nobody seems to know what the good news actually is.

Postscript: This isn't a slam. I get you, and your touch here is nice. I'm truly confused as to why you pulled up short.

Expand full comment
Bethel McGrew's avatar

"Jesus paid it all."

Expand full comment
James A. Weaks's avatar

Yes. I understand that. You understand that. But it's cryptic. What the heck does that even mean? How would Adams, who obviously has little or no correct information on Christianity, be able to understand that?

A wise Pastor once said, "A mist in the pulpit is a fog in the pew."

God can make much of this. I hope He does, and I applaud your effort here. Hopefully it reaches someone. I just want to encourage you to make it plain!

Expand full comment